Episode 79

Training Stronger Interviewers With Rubrics and AI Feedback

About this Episode

In this episode of Offer Accepted, Perpetual Ibe shares how Moniepoint is helping its interviewers grow with an AI agent that reviews their interviews. Perpetual joined Moniepoint five years ago as a Lead Technical Recruiter when the company had around 200 people, and she now leads talent for a team of 4,500. As the company moves into its next phase, she wants every candidate to have a consistent experience no matter who they meet.

Perpetual explains why her team built rubrics and a license to hire program before adding AI, and why she thinks people give an agent’s feedback a fair hearing. She also shares a moment when a recruiter trusted his own read over an AI tool, how interviewers have reacted to the pilot, and the bar raiser agent her team hopes to build next.

Topics

interviewing

This Episode's Guest

Perpetual Ibe

Head of Talent Acquisition @ Moniepoint

Perpetual Ibe is Head of Talent at Moniepoint, where she joined as a Lead Technical Recruiter and has grown with the company from 200 to 4,500 people. She previously recruited at ROAM Africa and is Offer Accepted’s first guest from the Africa region.

Takeaway 1

Give AI Something Worth Measuring 📋


Before Moniepoint's interviewer quality agent reviewed a single interview, Perpetual's TA team put in the work to define what good interviewing looks like across the company. That meant setting clear expectations for each role and giving interviewers the training to meet them. By the time the agent arrived, there was a shared standard to hold each interview against.

Why It Matters:
A while back, a candidate's poor interview experience was escalated to Perpetual's team. When they shared the feedback with the interviewer, she was genuinely shocked. She hadn't realized anything went wrong, and her first question was how she could improve. For Perpetual, that moment reflected something she sees often, especially with first-time managers, who usually want to do a good job and haven't yet been shown what good looks like. Giving interviewers that picture became the first step, well before any AI entered the conversation.

Quick Tips

  • Write rubrics by job family. A rubric spells out what success looks like in a role and how each skill will be assessed. Moniepoint already had interviewer guides, and the TA team built on them by mapping rubrics for roles like senior backend engineer, defining the skills someone needs to succeed and how interviews test for them.
  • Make training a prerequisite. Interviewers start from the same baseline when training comes before their first interview. Moniepoint's License to Hire program walks them through how to conduct the call and how to ask strong questions.
  • Create a continuous feedback cycle. Skills keep building when feedback on real interviews becomes a regular, expected part of the job. Perpetual added the agent so the lessons from the License to Hire program keep showing up well after the training ends.

Takeaway 2

Turn Every Interview Into a Coaching Moment 🎯


Training gives interviewers a starting point, and Perpetual wanted them to keep improving once they were conducting real interviews. To make that happen, her team built an interviewer quality agent that runs through interview transcripts and scores how closely each interviewer followed the standard they were trained on. It looks at question quality, including whether the interviewer probed with follow-up questions, along with how much of the conversation the interviewer spent talking. It also checks factors that shape the candidate's experience, like whether the interviewer seemed focused and explained the role and interview structure, and whether they covered the skills the rubric assigns to that interview.

Why It Matters:
Perpetual sees interviewing as a skill that many people don't realize they need to build. Strong interviewers pay close attention to a candidate's answers, cues, and behavior, which matters even more at a company like Moniepoint because most interviews are virtual. That attention starts before the call. With busy calendars, it's easy for an interviewer to arrive with little time to look over the interview kit and end up catching up on the candidate's resume once the conversation has started. The pilot is still too early for hard numbers, but Perpetual is already seeing more interviewers come in knowing who they're meeting, how the interview should flow, and which questions to ask.

Quick Tips

  • Aim for a 60/40 talk time. Candidates should do most of the talking so interviewers can actively listen and follow up where it helps. Before Moniepoint launched its training, Perpetual saw interviews where the interviewer spoke 70% of the time, which left her wondering how the candidate could have been fully assessed.
  • Let the agent deliver the feedback. Feedback from an agent arrives without the history and bias that can color a conversation between two people, so it's less likely to feel like an accusation. Perpetual finds interviewers are more willing to give the agent a chance, since the same note from a colleague can put someone on the defensive. Each report goes privately to the interviewer in Slack.
  • Pair each score with a next step. A score on its own can leave someone unsure what to change. The agent might give an interviewer 8 out of 10 on candidate experience for being warm and friendly, then suggest setting the interview structure up front next time.

Takeaway 3

Bring Everyone Along, From the CEO Down 🤝


An agent that reviews people's interviews works best when everyone involved trusts it, and Moniepoint built that trust starting at the top. The CEO is focused on how AI can make work better across the company, and seeing TA at the forefront earned his backing along with the CTO's. In meetings with hiring and functional managers, he reinforces that they're responsible for quality and should partner with TA to get there.

Why It Matters:
Perpetual has seen how easily people set aside something they view as a TA initiative, treating it as separate from their own job. When the CEO ties interviewer enablement to company and business goals, hiring managers have a reason to lean in. It reflects something Perpetual believes strongly, that hiring great people is a shared responsibility, from leadership to every interviewer on the loop.

Quick Tips

  • Keep the final call with the interviewer. Interviewers trust an AI tool more when they know it won't make decisions for them. In one case, a Moniepoint recruiter ran a transcript through an AI culture assessment tool that came back with a different read on a judgment dimension than what he'd seen in the conversation. He trusted his own experience, advanced the candidate, and that candidate went on to succeed in the process.
  • Let accuracy earn trust. People come to feedback with different levels of openness, and accurate feedback goes a long way toward bringing them in. Even before the pilot, one Moniepoint interviewer asked Perpetual whether anyone was checking how interviewers were doing because he wanted to know how to get better. For interviewers like him, the agent answered a need they already felt, and Perpetual expects accurate feedback to bring most others along over time.
  • Run your own interviews past AI first. Leaders who ask for feedback on their own interviews show their team that feedback is about growth. Before Moniepoint built the agent, Perpetual would ask Claude to evaluate her after her own interviews, checking whether she had asked the right questions, because she wanted to keep improving and give candidates a great experience.

What Hiring Excellence Means to Perpetual

For Perpetual, hiring excellence starts with everyone involved knowing the role they play, since hiring belongs to more than the recruiting team. She pictures a process where every candidate has the same experience and reaches the same outcome regardless of who they meet along the way. Getting there takes systems and processes working as the engine behind it. That consistency carries extra weight at Moniepoint, where Perpetual points out that candidates could also be customers given the nature of the business.

Watch the clip >>>

Perpetual's Recruiting Hot Take 🔥

Perpetual would like TA teams to stop seeing hiring managers as their customers. In a customer relationship, the instinct is to do what's asked and keep the customer happy. She sees TA as a partner that brings insight into what the market is saying and how a role should get filled. In some cases, a hiring manager simply says what they want and asks TA to go get it. Perpetual wants hiring managers to listen to the insight TA brings and work alongside their recruiters to reach the result together.

Watch the clip >>>

Timestamps

(00:00) Introduction

(00:43) Meet Perpetual Ibe

(01:46) Why fast-growing teams overlook interviewer quality

(03:12) What happens when interviewers are never shown how

(04:07) Why hiring quality is a shared responsibility

(04:58) Laying the groundwork with rubrics and a license to hire program

(07:37) The 4 things an interviewer quality agent checks

(11:17) How CEO buy-in made quality every manager's job

(12:40) When to trust your judgment over the AI

(17:33) Early pilot signals and how interviewers are responding

(19:08) Interviewers' feedback on the agent

(22:57) Advice for talent leaders starting interviewer enablement

(24:27) What comes after the interviewer quality agent

(25:55) Hiring excellence: Everybody knows the role they play

(27:16) Recruiting hot take: Hiring managers are partners, not customers

(28:47) Early career advice: Don't wait for permission

(31:23) Where to connect with Perpetual

Shannon Ogborn, host of Offer Accepted

Hosted By

Shannon Ogborn

RecOps Consultant & Community Lead @ Ashby

Shannon Ogborn is a Recruiting Ops expert with nearly ten years of experience at companies from Google to Hired Inc and more. She’s shining a spotlight onto what makes a recruiting strategy one of a kind.

Other Episodes

Hiring for Durable Skills to Build Teams That Last

Hiring for Durable Skills to Build Teams That Last

In this episode of Offer Accepted, Veronica Salcido, who leads talent and L&D at Growth Assistant, shares how her team traded a 50% churn rate among placed talent for a durable skills framework that runs from the first interview through onboarding, coaching, and performance reviews, along with the accountability system that ties recruiter success to what happens 90 days after someone joins.

Listen to this episode
Compensation Tactics to Empower Talent Team Performance

Compensation Tactics to Empower Talent Team Performance

In this episode, we chat with Virgile Raingeard, CEO at Figures to discuss how compensation strategy and communication plays a crucial role in your team's success.

Listen to this episode
Offer Accepted podcast logo

Join the Hiring Excellence movement

New episodes every month - subscribe here so you never miss out.